- Research article
- Open Access
Factors contributing to diagnostic delay of Caroli syndrome: a single-center, retrospective study
BMC Gastroenterology volume 20, Article number: 317 (2020)
Caroli syndrome (CS) is a rare congenital disorder without pathognomonic clinical symptoms or laboratory findings; therefore, the diagnosis is often delayed. The objective of this study was to investigate the diagnostic delay and associated risk factors in CS patients.
This was a retrospective analysis of 16 CS patients admitted to a single tertiary medical center on mainland China. The diagnostic timelines of CS patients were reviewed to demonstrate the initial findings of CS at diagnosis, the risk factors associated with diagnostic delay, and potential clues leading to early diagnosis.
The median diagnostic delay was 1.75 years (range: 1 month to 29 years, interquartile range: 6.2 years) in 16 enrolled CS patients. Sex, age, and initial symptoms were not associated with diagnostic delay. 87.5% of CS patients were diagnosed by imaging, and the accuracies of ultrasonography, computed tomography (CT), and magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography were 25, 69.2, and 83.3%, respectively. The median diagnostic delays for patients with or without CT performed at the first hospital visited according to physician and radiologist suspicion of the diagnosis were 7.4 months and 6 years, respectively (p = 0.021). Hepatic cysts with splenomegaly were detected by ultrasound in over half of CS patients.
The majority of CS patients were not diagnosed until complications of portal hypertension had already developed. Recognition and early suspicion of the disease were important factors influencing diagnostic delay of CS. Hepatic cysts plus splenomegaly detected by US might raise the clinical suspicion to include CS in the differential diagnosis.
Caroli syndrome (CS) is a rare congenital disorder characterized by segmental dilatation of the intrahepatic ducts and hepatic fibrosis . The incidence of CS is estimated to be 1 per million of the population . Although the pathoetiology of CS is still poorly understood, CS is known to be an autosomal recessive hereditary disorder involving malformation of the ductal plates and associated periportal fibrosis .
CS has no pathognomonic clinical symptoms or signs . It can manifest insidiously, with patients presenting in two main ways: intrahepatic ductal ectasia and bile stagnation (i.e., recurrent cholangitis and/or cholangiolithiasis) or portal hypertension (i.e., hypersplenism, gastrointestinal bleeding, ascites) . CS has also been reported in association with cystic renal disease, pancreatic cysts, cavernomatous transformation of the portal vein, and an increased risk of cholangiocarcinoma .
Histopathology is useful for securing a definitive diagnosis, but imaging modalities including ultrasonography (US), computed tomography (CT), and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) remain the first-line diagnostic methods due to their noninvasiveness and convenience . Although an early diagnosis of CS is the first step to early intervention, complication control, and surveillance, there is scarce evidence on the clinical parameters that influence early diagnosis or how imaging and their features might influence the diagnostic timeline of CS patients .
We therefore performed a single-center retrospective study to review the diagnostic timelines of 16 CS patients to investigate the clinical features at diagnosis, the risk factors associated with diagnostic delay, and potential clues leading to early diagnosis.
Sixteen CS patients were admitted to Peking Union Medical College Hospital between January 12,005 and August 12,019. Demographic data, symptoms, laboratory results, detailed imaging findings, associated conditions, histopathology results, and other information related to CS diagnosis including residential location, family history, and hospitals visited were collected from the medical records. A diagnostic timeline was drawn for each patient using these data. We defined diagnostic delay as the time between initial clinical presentation and final diagnosis.
Data were analyzed using SPSS for Windows Version 23.0 (IBM Statistics Inc., Chicago, IL). Continuous variables were reported as means ± standard deviation (SD) and compared using Student’s t-test if determined as normally distributed according to the Shapiro-Wilk test. Otherwise, they were reported as median values with interquartile ranges (IQR) and compared using the Mann-Whitney U test. Categorical variables were analyzed using the chi-squared test. Both continuous and categorical variables were analyzed using logistic regression or Spearman’s coefficient. A p-value < 0.05 was considered statistically significant. Since diagnostic delay was not normally distributed, we took the natural logarithm (ln) of the diagnostic delay (ln (diagnostic delay)), which was normally distributed, which allowed the use of t-tests with this variable.
Ten CS patients were male and six were female, with a male to female ratio of 5:3. The median age of symptom onset was 7 years of age (range: 1 month to 38 years, IQR: 15.5 years), the median age of first clinic visit was 10 years of age (range: 1 month to 38 years, IQR: 17.6 years), and the median age at diagnosis was 15 years of age (range: 8 months to 39 years, IQR: 24.5 years). The median diagnostic delay, which was defined as the time between initial clinical presentation and final diagnosis, was 1.75 years (range: 1 month to 29 years, IQR: 6.2 years). Sex, age of symptom onset, age at first clinic visit, and age at diagnosis were not significantly associated with diagnostic delay (Table 1).
Initial clinical presentation
Initial symptoms of the 16 CS patients included fever (n = 6), abdominal pain (n = 3), abdominal distention (n = 8), gastrointestinal bleeding (n = 1), and fatigue (n = 1). Most initial symptoms led directly to a first clinic visit, with the exception of three patients who had abdominal distention as the initial symptom but only presented later to hospital for other reasons (Table 2). None of these initial symptoms were associated with diagnostic delay (Table 1). Three patients had a positive family history, but similarly this was not associated with diagnostic delay (Table 1).
Laboratory findings at diagnosis included decreased peripheral white blood cell count (n = 11), anemia (n = 11), and decreased platelet count (n = 10). Ten patients had pancytopenia. Some patients had abnormal liver function, with elevated serum alanine aminotransferase (ALT) (n = 2), elevated serum bilirubin (n = 2), decreased serum albumin (n = 2), and prolonged prothrombin time (PT) (n = 5). Of note, the two patients with elevated ALT had cholangitis when admitted, and their ALT levels returned to normal after anti-microbial treatment. Two patients had increased serum creatinine levels, both of whom had multiple renal cysts.
Positive autoantibodies were present in four CS patients: antinuclear antibodies (ANA) were tested in ten patients and two were positive; anti-mitochondrial antibodies (M2 subtype; AMA-M2) were tested in seven patients and two were positive; and anti-smooth muscle antibodies (SMA) were tested in seven patients and one was positive. Two patients were initially misdiagnosed as having autoimmune disease. The first misdiagnosed patient was a 21-year-old man with positive ANA and slightly elevated aspartate transaminase (AST) and immunoglobulin G (IgG), who was misdiagnosed with autoimmune hepatitis (AIH) and was treated with corticosteroids and azathioprine for 1 month. There was no clinical improvement, and histopathological examination of his liver biopsy secured a diagnosis of CS. The other misdiagnosed patient was a 33-year-old woman who presented with low-grade fever and abdominal distention who had positive ANA and AMA-M2 and slightly elevated gamma-glutamyltransferase (GGT) and alkaline phosphatase (ALP). She was initially misdiagnosed with primary biliary cholangitis (PBC) and treated with corticosteroids and ursodeoxycholic acid for 3 months. Again, there was no clinical improvement and she developed recurrent cholangitis. Magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography (MRCP) was performed, and the diagnosis of CS was made according to typical imaging findings. Her symptoms were soon controlled with antibiotics, and her GGT and ALP returned to normal.
Lower white blood cell (WBC) counts (5 years vs. 4 months; p = 0.01), lower platelet (PLT) counts (4.5 years vs. 6.5 months; p = 0.01), and pancytopenia (4.5 years vs. 6.5 months; p = 0.01) at diagnosis were associated with longer diagnostic delay. There were no other significant associations between laboratory findings and diagnostic delay (Table 1).
All 16 CS patients were examined by US before diagnosis, 13 were examined by CT with or without contrast, and 12 were investigated by MRCP. Some patients had several imaging studies at different hospitals before the final diagnosis was secured. On average, US was performed 1.9 times and CT 1.3 times per patient before diagnosis. The accuracies of US, CT, and MRCP were 25, 69.2, and 83.3%, respectively (Table 3). Fourteen patients were diagnosed by imaging, while two patients were finally diagnosed from the histopathological appearances on liver biopsy.
All 16 patients had US performed during the first visit to a hospital, while eight patients also had CT scans due to suspicions raised by physicians and radiologists. CT performed at the first hospital visited was associated with a statistically significant shorter diagnostic delay (p = 0.021; Table 1). The median diagnostic delays for patients with CT performed or not performed at the first hospital visit were 7.4 months and 6 years, respectively.
We examined the US signs in CS patients at their first hospital visit. Diffusive hepatic lesions, hepatic cysts, splenomegaly, and renal cysts were reported in 10 (62.5%), 10 (62.5%), 15 (93.8%), and 8 (50%) patients, respectively. The combination of diffuse hepatic lesions plus splenomegaly, hepatic cysts plus splenomegaly, and renal cysts plus splenomegaly were found in 10 (62.5%), 9 (56.3%), and 8 (50%) patients, respectively (Table 4).
The diagnostic timelines of all 16 patients were drawn to visualize important diagnostic time points, disease phase at diagnosis, and imaging modalities used to make the diagnosis (Fig. 1). We divided the CS course into three phases: phase 1 (four patients, 25%), no proof of portal hypertension (i.e., hypersplenism); phase 2 (ten patients, 62.5%), discovered complications of portal hypertension without variceal bleeding; and phase 3 (2 patients, 12.5%), at least one recorded variceal bleed.
Caroli syndrome (CS) is a rare congenital disorder associated with ductal plate malformation and hepatic fibrosis . CS is usually diagnosed during childhood or adolescence but may be diagnosed in adulthood [10, 11], consistent with our findings. Fifty percent of our CS patients developed symptoms before 6 years of age, and 18.75% of patients had symptom onset in adulthood. However, only 25% patients were correctly diagnosed before 6 years and 37.5% patients were not diagnosed until adulthood. The majority of patients already had complications of portal hypertension at the time of diagnosis and some even had severe gastrointestinal bleeding due to esophagogastric varices. There was also a wide range of diagnostic delay in our patients, from 1 month to as long as 29 years. However, to our best knowledge, there is no published evidence on the clinical factors influencing diagnostic delay in CS patients, indicating that diagnostic delay of CS patients might be a severe yet overlooked problem. We therefore attempted to analyze possible factors associated with diagnostic delay in CS patients to identify any clinical clues that could facilitate earlier diagnosis.
As previously reported, CS patients can present with fever and abdominal pain due to recurrent cholangitis, fatigue and ecchymosis due to hypersplenism, gastrointestinal bleeding due to varices, and non-specific digestive symptoms such as anorexia and abdominal distention [1, 4]. The most common initial symptoms in CS patients in our cohort were non-specific abdominal distention followed by fever, abdominal pain, variceal bleeding, and fatigue. Although three out of the eight patients initially presenting with abdominal distention did not seek immediate medical advice, which might have delayed the diagnosis of CS, there was no significant difference in diagnostic delay between patients with different initial symptoms.
Similarly, the laboratory findings in CS patients were not discriminative. Leukopenia, thrombopenia, and pancytopenia were associated with longer diagnostic delay. However, this was likely to be due to patients with longer diagnostic delay being more likely to have hypersplenism. Other laboratory abnormalities including increased ALT and bilirubin, decreased albumin, and prolonged PT were not associated with diagnostic delay. Interestingly, autoantibodies were positive in four (25%) of our CS patients, which has not previously been reported. Although the presence of these autoantibodies in AIH and PBC is well established, these autoantibodies are not reported to be associated with CS , which might therefore mislead the diagnosis. Indeed, these positive autoantibody results did lead to, or at least contribute to, the initial misdiagnosis of two CS patients. It is important to be aware of the co-existence of autoantibodies and CS, since immunosuppressive therapy might lead to clinical exacerbation of CS.
Imaging studies remain the primary diagnostic modality in patients with CS due to their non-invasiveness compared to liver biopsy, which when performed is usually to establish the degree of fibrosis [1, 4]. Although a range of PKHD1 mutations are associated with CS, the diagnosis is usually made through the characteristic clinical picture, typical imaging features with or without histological confirmation, and exclusion of other hepatic diseases leading to hepatic fibrosis and bile duct dilatation. Most (87.5%) of our patients were diagnosed according to typical imaging features by US, CT, and MRI. The diagnosis of CS relies on demonstrating cystic dilatation of intrahepatic bile ducts in continuity with the biliary tree as well as signs of hepatic fibrosis. US features of the liver in CS include intrahepatic cystic anechoic areas in which fibrovascular bundles, stones, and linear bridging or septa may be present [1, 13]. Nevertheless, it is often difficult for radiologists to differentiate by US intrahepatic cysts caused by CS from cysts arising through other causes such as polycystic liver disease, and interobserver variability according to radiologist experience in making the diagnosis of CS has been reported . In our study, the accuracy of diagnosing CS by US was only 25%, and some patients were not successfully diagnosed by US at first but were later diagnosed by another US performed in another hospital. Taking this interobserver variance into account, the actual accuracy of US for CS might be even lower.
In our study, CT scans were much more accurate than US (69.2%). The “central dot sign” on CT (Fig. 2), which refers to small foci of strong contrast enhancement within cystic lesions, is thought to correspond to portal radicles bridging dilatations and thus be pathognomonic of CS . MRCP can establish the diagnosis of CS by revealing connections between bile duct ectasias and the normal biliary tract (Fig. 3) as well as ruling out other conditions like multiple liver abscesses and polycystic liver disease [13, 14]. The accuracy of MRCP was 83.3% in our study, similar to previously reported [5, 13]. In our study, the use of MRI/MRCP was limited, particularly in children. This was because: (i) MRI examination requires good patient cooperation, and it its often difficult for children to cooperate with the examination; (ii) patients are not usually sedated during MRI in China, even in tertiary hospitals, not least due to the limited resources of many patients; and (iii) CT scans are cheaper than MRI/MRCP, and CT scans are usually better covered by medical insurance than MRI/MRCP in most areas of China. Nevertheless, patients who had a CT scan performed due to physician or radiologist suspicion at the first hospital visited had a significantly shorter diagnostic delay. This was the only risk factor associated with diagnostic delay in our study, suggesting that a high index of suspicion for the disease might be the most important factor influencing diagnostic delay in CS, whose rarity often leads to poor awareness of the condition and thus misdiagnosis.
Due to the retrospective nature of the study, we were only able to locate the previous CT images in four patients (two CT and two contrast CT scans), with the longest interval of 4 years between previous and current CT scans. These scans reported non-specific findings such as “hepatic cyst”, “polycystic liver”, and “focal cystic mass of bile duct”, with some cases also reporting “dilatations of intrahepatic bile ducts”. These scans were compared by an experienced radiologist, and no significant differences were observed between the previous and current CT scans. This finding is consistent with our suggestion that the low index of suspicion for CS might be the most important factor leading to diagnostic delay. However, since these comparative imaging data are limited and the intervals between CT scans were relatively short, further studies are required to further investigate radiological misdiagnosis.
US was nearly always the first-line imaging modality due to its low cost and convenience, despite its suboptimal accuracy. Splenomegaly, diffusive hepatic lesions, and hepatic cysts were the most common US findings in CS. When combined, diffusive hepatic lesions plus splenomegaly and hepatic cysts plus splenomegaly were found in over half of our CS patients. However, diffusive hepatic lesions plus splenomegaly can also be found in a variety of other conditions including portal hypertension caused by thrombosis or dysplasia of the portal venous system, congenital disorders such as Niemann-Pick disease, congenital hepatic fibroses other than CS, and even malignancies like lymphoma . Hepatic cysts with splenomegaly have a narrower differential diagnosis, mainly other hepatic cystic diseases including polycystic kidney disease , hepatic peribiliary cysts (which only rarely lead to splenomegaly) , and, even more rarely, malignant cystic diseases of the liver and spleen, which are easily differentiated . Thus, hepatic cysts plus splenomegaly on US might provide a useful clue to physicians and thus might shorten the diagnostic delay of CS. Based on our results, Fig. 4 shows our proposed clinical practice workflow when CS is suspected.
This study has several limitations. First, the study was retrospective, and although we detected possible risk factors associated with diagnostic delay of CS patients, they require further verification. Second, since CS is rare the sample was relatively small, and the results require validation in larger samples. Third, we took the natural logarithm of diagnostic delay to make it normally distributed so that it could be compared using the t-test, which is more susceptible to outliers than the U test. Finally, we are a tertiary hospital and this is a single-center study, which could introduce bias in that patients sent to our hospital might be more complicated and difficult to diagnose.
CS can be insidious and has no distinguishing symptoms or laboratory findings. The majority of patients were not diagnosed until complications of portal hypertension had already developed. Some patients might have positive autoantibodies, which could be deceptive and lead to misdiagnosis. US was not ideally accurate, but hepatic cysts with splenomegaly detected by US might raise the diagnostic index of suspicion for CS. Early suspicion of the disease might be the most important factor influencing diagnostic delay of CS.
Availability of data and materials
All data supporting our findings can be found within the manuscript.
Magnetic resonance imaging
Anti-mitochondrial antibodies (M2 subtype)
Anti-smooth muscle antibodies
White blood cell
Magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography
Primary biliary cholangitis
- CT + C:
Computed tomography with contrast
Positron emission tomography/computed tomography
Yonem O, Bayraktar Y. Clinical characteristics of Caroli's syndrome. World J Gastroenterol. 2007;13(13):1934–7.
Bakoyiannis A, Delis S, Triantopoulou C, Dervenis C. Rare cystic liver lesions: a diagnostic and managing challenge. World J Gastroenterol. 2013;19(43):7603–19.
Shorbagi A, Bayraktar Y. Experience of a single center with congenital hepatic fibrosis: a review of the literature. World J Gastroenterol. 2010;16(6):683–90.
Wang ZX, Li YG, Wang RL, Li YW, Li ZY, Wang LF, Yang HY, Zhu Y, Wang Y, Bai YF, et al. Clinical classification of Caroli’s disease: an analysis of 30 patients. HPB (Oxford). 2015;17(3):278–83.
Zhang DY, Ji ZF, Shen XZ, Liu HY, Pan BJ, Dong L. Caroli’s disease: a report of 14 patients and review of the literature. J Dig Dis. 2012;13(9):491–5.
Park E, Lee JM, Ahn YH, Kang HG, Ha II, Lee JH, Park YS, Kim NK, Park WY, Cheong HI. Hepatorenal fibrocystic diseases in children. Pediatr Nephrol. 2016;31(1):113–9.
Cannella R, Giambelluca D, Diamarco M, Caruana G, Cutaia G, Midiri M, Salvaggio G. Congenital cystic lesions of the bile ducts: Imaging-Based Diagnosis. Curr Probl Diagn Radiol. 2020;49(4):285-93.
Lendoire JC, Raffin G, Grondona J, Bracco R, Russi R, Ardiles V, Gondolesi G, Defelitto J, de Santibanes E, Imventarza O. Caroli’s disease: report of surgical options and long-term outcome of patients treated in Argentina. Multicenter study. J Gastrointest Surg. 2011;15(10):1814–9.
Bettini G, Mandrioli L, Morini M. Bile duct dysplasia and congenital hepatic fibrosis associated with polycystic kidney (Caroli syndrome) in a rat. Vet Pathol. 2003;40(6):693–4.
Schiano TD, Fiel MI, Miller CM, Bodenheimer HC Jr, Min AD. Adult presentation of Caroli’s syndrome treated with orthotopic liver transplantation. Am J Gastroenterol. 1997;92(10):1938–40.
Keane F, Hadzic N, Wilkinson ML, Qureshi S, Reid C, Baker AJ, Mieli-Vergani G. Neonatal presentation of Caroli’s disease. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 1997;77(2):F145–6.
Zhang WC, Zhao FR, Chen J, Chen WX. Meta-analysis: diagnostic accuracy of antinuclear antibodies, smooth muscle antibodies and antibodies to a soluble liver antigen/liver pancreas in autoimmune hepatitis. PLoS One. 2014;9(3):e92267.
Kassahun WT, Kahn T, Wittekind C, Mossner J, Caca K, Hauss J, Lamesch P. Caroli's disease: liver resection and liver transplantation. Experience in 33 patients. Surgery. 2005;138(5):888–98.
Hwang MJ, Kim TN. Diffuse-type Caroli disease with characteristic central dot sign complicated by multiple intrahepatic and common bile duct stones. Clin Endosc. 2017;50(4):400–3.
Tchelepi H, Ralls PW, Radin R, Grant E. Sonography of diffuse liver disease. J Ultrasound Med. 2002;21(9):1023–32 quiz 1033-1024.
Hogan MC, Abebe K, Torres VE, Chapman AB, Bae KT, Tao C, Sun H, Perrone RD, Steinman TI, Braun W, et al. Liver involvement in early autosomal-dominant polycystic kidney disease. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2015;13(1):155–164.e156.
Yokomichi H, Tsuji K, Hayashi Y, Kaneko M, Nakadoi K, Ishida Y, Kuwabara T, Tsumuna T, Sumida T, Nagata S, et al. A case of multiple hepatic peribiliary cysts which contributed to the obstructive jaundice and led to liver failure at the young man with von Recklinghausen’s disease. Hepatol Res. 2006;35(3):222–7.
Das A, Arya SV, Soni N, Gowda GG, Kalwaniya DS. A rare presentation of hepatic and splenic cystic malignant fibrous histiocytoma: a case report and literature review. Int J Surg Case Rep. 2013;4(1):139–41.
Medical Education Quality Project 2019 by Peking Union Medical College (2019zlgc0104) provided the financial support for polishing the language in the article and publication.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
The study protocol was approved by the Ethics Committee of Peking Union Medical College Hospital (Ref: S-K 921). The ethics committee waived the requirement for informed consent because anonymous data were analyzed retrospectively.
Consent for publication
Written informed consent to publish in the study was obtained from participants or their parent or legal guardian in the case of children under 16.
The authors declare that they have no competing interests.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
About this article
Cite this article
Shi, W., Huang, Xm., Feng, Yl. et al. Factors contributing to diagnostic delay of Caroli syndrome: a single-center, retrospective study. BMC Gastroenterol 20, 317 (2020). https://doi.org/10.1186/s12876-020-01442-5
- Caroli syndrome