Skip to main content

Table 4 Between and within group comparisons at week 4

From: A randomised controlled trial of a probiotic ‘functional food’ in the management of irritable bowel syndrome

Study parameter

Active product

Control product

Active versus control

 

n

Mean (week 4–baseline) (SD)

p value* (change from baseline)

n

Mean (week 4–baseline) (SD)

p value* (change from baseline)

p value**

IBS-SSS

41

−53.35 (81.98)

<0.002

44

−31.11 (78.57)

0.010

0.233

Birmingham IBS symptom scale

       

Constipation

59

9.44 (20.40)

<0.001

49

15.10 (21.59)

<0.001

0.131

Diarrhoea

59

3.88 (12.26)

0.007

2.22 (10.17)

0.106

0.616

Pain

60

7.89 (14.70)

<0.001

11.22 (18.34)

<0.001

0.367

Total score

60

6.10 (10.83)

<0.001

8.28 (11.10)

<0.001

0.251

IBS specific symptoms

       

Pain

60

−0.33 (1.19)

0.087

49

−0.61 (1.36)

0.001

0.109

Bloating

−0.66 (1.35)

<0.001

48

−0.68 (1.12)

<0.001

0.432

Flatulence

−0.51 (1.24)

<0.001

49

−0.36 (1.07)

0.0017

0.955

Composite score

−1.48 (3.03)

0.002

49

−1.69 (2.99)

<0.001

0.264

Stool frequency

417

0.07 (0.89)

0.202

341

0.04 (0.85)

0.607

0.648

Stool consistency

341

0.13 (1.20)

0.240

269

0.31 (1.30)

0.007

0.184

Bowel movement difficulty

341

−0.24 (0.97)

0.004

271

−0.28 (0.89)

0.011

0.450

IBS Quality of life

       

Dysphoria

60

9.78 (16.89)

<0.001

50

7.53 (15.54)

0.002

0.875

Activity interference

60

5.68 (10.97)

0.003

50

5.07 (13.77)

0.008

0.769

Body image

60

6.63 (16.28)

<0.001

50

8.13 (17.37)

0.004

0.134

Health worry

60

7.92 (15.20)

0.001

50

5.75 (16.17)

0.009

0.958

Food avoidance

60

9.58 (16.01)

0.002

50

4.42 (18.76)

0.078

0.121

Social reaction

60

7.33 (14.23)

0.003

50

4.17 (14.10)

0.029

0.769

Sexual

59

4.24 (15.68)

0.171

48

4.17 (20.36)

0.125

0.853

Relationship

60

7.15 (15.54)

<0.001

50

1.92 (12.43)

0.217

0.139

Total score

60

7.60 (10.88)

<0.001

50

5.69 (12.60)

0.004

0.979

  1. *ANCOVA with centre as a random effect, baseline as a covariate and product as a fixed effect.
  2. **Ordinal logistic regression with centre and product fixed effects.
  3. Stool frequency, consistency and bowel movement difficulty were recorded daily and therefore n represents the number of data items (days) included in analysis for these items.