Skip to main content

Table 1 Comparison of baseline characteristics between the high-PMTR region and low-PMTR region, stratified by HSA PTR rate

From: Primary tumor resection with or without metastasectomy for left- and right-sided stage IV colorectal cancer: an instrumental variable analysis

 

Left-sided, n = 29,402

Right-sided, n = 20,931

High PTR

Low PTR

p

High PTR

Low PTR

p

High PMTR

Low PMTR

High PMTR

Low PMTR

High PMTR

Low PMTR

High PMTR

Low PMTR

Sex = Female

1181 (38.7)

4910 (41.6)

4846 (41.7)

1219 (42.0)

0.017

1102 (50.6)

4220 (51.2)

4469 (52.7)

1027 (50.7)

0.1

Age, years

    

 < 0.001

    

0.001

 < 50

622 (20.4)

2283 (19.3)

2191 (18.8)

504 (17.3)

 

268 (12.3)

1006 (12.2)

998 (11.8)

210 (10.4)

 

50–59

830 (27.2)

3104 (26.3)

2949 (25.3)

715 (24.6)

 

490 (22.5)

1631 (19.8)

1767 (20.8)

394 (19.5)

 

60–69

812 (26.6)

3080 (26.1)

3046 (26.2)

738 (25.4)

 

597 (27.4)

2085 (25.3)

2099 (24.8)

528 (26.1)

 

70–79

529 (17.3)

2031 (17.2)

2108 (18.1)

550 (18.9)

 

475 (21.8)

1912 (23.2)

1963 (23.1)

488 (24.1)

 

 ≥ 80

261 (8.5)

1311 (11.1)

1340 (11.5)

398 (13.7)

 

350 (16.1)

1612 (19.5)

1653 (19.5)

405 (20.0)

 

Race

    

 < 0.001

    

 < 0.001

Non-Hispanic White

2237 (73.2)

6486 (54.9)

8058 (69.3)

2096 (72.2)

 

1583 (72.6)

4820 (58.5)

5890 (69.5)

1506 (74.4)

 

Non-Hispanic Black

401 (13.1)

1381 (11.7)

1779 (15.3)

179 (6.2)

 

379 (17.4)

1240 (15.0)

1719 (20.3)

168 (8.3)

 

H ispanic

254 (8.3)

2267 (19.2)

647 (5.6)

465 (16.0)

 

145 (6.7)

1359 (16.5)

383 (4.5)

267 (13.2)

 

Other

162 (5.3)

1675 (14.2)

1150 (9.9)

165 (5.7)

 

73 (3.3)

827 (10.0)

488 (5.8)

84 (4.1)

 

Marital status

    

 < 0.001

    

0.014

Widowed

343 (11.2)

1237 (10.5)

1424 (12.2)

388 (13.4)

 

376 (17.2)

1325 (16.1)

1510 (17.8)

331 (16.3)

 

Married

1605 (52.6)

6155 (52.1)

5904 (50.7)

1504 (51.8)

 

1136 (52.1)

4225 (51.2)

4257 (50.2)

1079 (53.3)

 

Other

1106 (36.2)

4417 (37.4)

4306 (37.0)

1013 (34.9)

 

668 (30.6)

2696 (32.7)

2713 (32.0)

615 (30.4)

 

Year of diagnosis

    

0.825

    

0.144

2005–2007

803 (26.3)

3144 (26.6)

3048 (26.2)

761 (26.2)

 

568 (26.1)

2287 (27.7)

2300 (27.1)

529 (26.1)

 

2008–2010

798 (26.1)

3142 (26.6)

3059 (26.3)

796 (27.4)

 

580 (26.6)

2308 (28.0)

2295 (27.1)

572 (28.2)

 

2011–2015

1453 (47.6)

5523 (46.8)

5527 (47.5)

1348 (46.4)

 

1032 (47.3)

3651 (44.3)

3885 (45.8)

924 (45.6)

 

Tumor size, cm

    

 < 0.001

    

 < 0.001

 < 2

69 (2.3)

248 (2.1)

226 (1.9)

66 (2.3)

 

41 (1.9)

151 (1.8)

137 (1.6)

42 (2.1)

 

 ≥ 2, < 4

453 (14.8)

1719 (14.6)

1672 (14.4)

374 (12.9)

 

330 (15.1)

1217 (14.8)

1237 (14.6)

269 (13.3)

 

 ≥ 4, < 6

852 (27.9)

3197 (27.1)

3078 (26.5)

707 (24.3)

 

621 (28.5)

2254 (27.3)

2311 (27.3)

523 (25.8)

 

 ≥ 6

762 (25.0)

2829 (24.0)

2866 (24.6)

636 (21.9)

 

683 (31.3)

2601 (31.5)

2606 (30.7)

583 (28.8)

 

Unknown

918 (30.1)

3816 (32.3)

3792 (32.6)

1122 (38.6)

 

505 (23.2)

2023 (24.5)

2189 (25.8)

608 (30.0)

 

Tumor grade

    

 < 0.001

    

 < 0.001

Grade1/2

1946 (63.7)

7374 (62.4)

7215 (62.0)

1816 (62.5)

 

1164 (53.4)

4529 (54.9)

4513 (53.2)

1067 (52.7)

 

Grade3/4

590 (19.3)

2347 (19.9)

2088 (17.9)

544 (18.7)

 

695 (31.9)

2448 (29.7)

2472 (29.2)

601 (29.7)

 

Unknown

518 (17.0)

2088 (17.7)

2331 (20.0)

545 (18.8)

 

321 (14.7)

1269 (15.4)

1495 (17.6)

357 (17.6)

 

T stage

    

 < 0.001

    

 < 0.001

Tis

5 (0.2)

21 (0.2)

21 (0.2)

3 (0.1)

 

2 (0.1)

13 (0.2)

11 (0.1)

7 (0.3)

 

T1

247 (8.1)

1250 (10.6)

1039 (8.9)

305 (10.5)

 

151 (6.9)

591 (7.2)

542 (6.4)

154 (7.6)

 

T2

70 (2.3)

271 (2.3)

300 (2.6)

60 (2.1)

 

31 (1.4)

152 (1.8)

158 (1.9)

33 (1.6)

 

T3

1340 (43.9)

4632 (39.2)

4596 (39.5)

1107 (38.1)

 

843 (38.7)

3116 (37.8)

3111 (36.7)

712 (35.2)

 

T4

759 (24.9)

2778 (23.5)

2871 (24.7)

661 (22.8)

 

794 (36.4)

2794 (33.9)

2940 (34.7)

680 (33.6)

 

Unknown

633 (20.7)

2857 (24.2)

2807 (24.1)

769 (26.5)

 

359 (16.5)

1580 (19.2)

1718 (20.3)

439 (21.7)

 

N stage

    

 < 0.001

    

0.015

N0

952 (31.2)

3748 (31.7)

3652 (31.4)

907 (31.2)

 

539 (24.7)

2175 (26.4)

2119 (25.0)

537 (26.5)

 

N1

896 (29.3)

3608 (30.6)

3682 (31.6)

914 (31.5)

 

622 (28.5)

2362 (28.6)

2540 (30.0)

581 (28.7)

 

N2

841 (27.5)

2835 (24.0)

2839 (24.4)

618 (21.3)

 

809 (37.1)

2801 (34.0)

2914 (34.4)

662 (32.7)

 

Unknown

365 (12.0)

1618 (13.7)

1461 (12.6)

466 (16.0)

 

210 (9.6)

908 (11.0)

907 (10.7)

245 (12.1)

 
  1. P < 0.05 indicates a significant difference between the groups
  2. HSA, health service area; PMTR, primary tumor resection plus metastasectomy; PTR, primary tumor resection